Fair Principle 10: Commercial models and offerings shall be consistent and reasonable, not combining different models for the benefit of the vendor’s revenue

Fair Principle 10: Commercial models and offerings shall be consistent and reasonable, not combining different models for the benefit of the vendor’s revenue

2022-09-27 Fair Principles 10BTuesday 27 September 2022

Business users associations Beltug, Voice, Cigref and CIO Platform Nederland call for a balanced cloud market: 11 fair principles to unleash Europe’s digital potential. Fair principle 9 calls for commercial models to not be changed unilaterally and be adhering to an active ‘opt-in’ principle.

Vendors of business software and customers should all start with the same end in mind; a clear, consistent and well-defined commercial model that’s a win-win for both parties. But practice is different.  

Over the years, the way in which software is licensed has been evolving. There are licences per CPU, user, device, revenue, documents processed in a software, extra security features, ect. It has become complex to calculate the needed licenses within an organisation. On top of that, vendors change their models over the time the software is used, often with extra costs and limited if any benefits to the user organisations.  

For instance: 

  • A change from a machine-based towards a user-based model. With the machine-based licence budgeting was easy, you count the number of machines and multiply this by the cost per licence. But in the situation where several people use the same machine, when the licencing model changes to a per user model, not only do the license costs change dramatically, the company also has to track and log who is using the machines and when. It is clear that the use case needs to be completely re-analysed if such a change is imposed. Furthermore, for the user organisation this change of model brings a lot of extra costs, but no benefit whatsoever. 

  • Perpetual licence model or subscription model, not both. In the past, business software was often licenced in perpetuity, for which of course came at a substantial cost. But when the vendor changes the commercial model to a subscription model, which happens very often and usually unilaterally, the expected cost of ownership changes substantially. And when this change happens during a commitment term, it makes cost calculation extremely difficult. The subscription model with the recurring subscription charges resembles the maintenance and support fee that came with the perpetual licence, but business users are not compensated for their earlier investment in the licence itself. Because of vendor lock in, the customer has limited alternatives if the product is only continued under a subscription model: either run the original software without maintenance and support, risk being left with no help if the software crashes or other software platforms connected with it are upgraded, or follow the vendor change to subscription model. 

Business users are asking for a clear cost of ownership, possibility for cost forecasting etc. That is precisely why this tenth principle is important; commercial models and offerings shall be consistent and reasonable, not combining different models for the benefit of the vendor’s revenue. 

« Back

More news

Blog: What knowledge and tools should the Supervisory Board have in order to be able to assess the risks of applying artificial intelligence?

2023-12-05 | Blog | Frank FerroMonday 04 December 2023 Are you as part of a (supervisory) board looking for more guidance and control on AI? Or are you interested in this? Find insights and leads in this blog by Frank Ferro (Director Insights, PostNL). full story

CIO of the Year 2023 – Aart Rupert, Damen

2023-11-27 | CIO DAY 2023 | Aart RupertMonday 27 November 2023 During a whirlwind show at CIODAY, the CIO of the Year 2023 was announced. full story

Blog The new 'normal' / Change management

2023-11-20 - Blog GerJan HuisjesMonday 20 November 2023 Gerjan Huisjes (Director, VolkerWessels ITBV) shares his thoughts and advice on the changing environment for the CIO, employees and the world. What is our role in the 'new normal' and how do we deal with it? Read it below! full story

Digital technology, (continuing) livelihoods and the 2023 elections

2023-11-13 | NB | Digitale technologie, (voort-)bestaanszekerheid en de verkiezingen van 2023 .jpgMonday 13 November 2023 On Wednesday November 22nd, the Netherlands will go to the polls. More than two and a half years after the previous elections, and less than two years after the Rutte IV Cabinet took office. And yet the situation is completely different. full story

View all news items through the archive

Close